Michael Vaughan called for either Stuart Broad (left) or James Anderson (right) to be dropped after a dismal first Test loss to Pakistan.
Michael Vaughan called for either Stuart Broad (left) or James Anderson (right) to be dropped after a dismal first Test loss to Pakistan.

‘You haven’t won yet’: Vaughan and Broad trade barbs

MICHAEL Vaughan warned Stuart Broad he was not beyond criticism after the England paceman was angered by his former captain's comments prior to the ongoing second Test against Pakistan at Headingley.

England came under fire after a shambolic display in a nine-wicket defeat by Pakistan in the first Test at Lord's left them 1-0 down in a two-match series.

Vaughan led the way, suggesting England should drop either Broad or James Anderson - their two most successful Test bowlers of all time - if only to "ruffle feathers".

Stuart Broad responded to Michael Vaughan’s call for his axing with three wickets on Friday.
Stuart Broad responded to Michael Vaughan’s call for his axing with three wickets on Friday.

Broad and Anderson responded by taking three wickets apiece as Pakistan were dismissed for just 174 on Friday's first day of the second Test.

A rain delayed day two then saw the hosts build a 128 run lead to be at 7/302 at stumps.

But before England built their lead, Broad felt the need to respond to Vaughan's criticism, saying he no longer had "much insight into the England changing room at all".

"I don't think the players talk to him about cricket or what's going on," Broad added.

"I'm not going to hold a personal grudge if someone criticises me, particularly if I feel like I deserve it.

Vaughan warned Broad he was not beyond criticism after the England paceman was angered by his former captain’s comments.
Vaughan warned Broad he was not beyond criticism after the England paceman was angered by his former captain’s comments.

"I'm friends with Vaughany. He was a fantastic captain to me, gave me a great opportunity … he's great company. But I just didn't feel like I really deserved that."

During the morning rain delay on Saturday's second day, Vaughan questioned the timing of Broad's response.

"You have to be careful in sport that comments can come back to bite you," Vaughan told BBC Radio's Test Match Special.

"I got the sense last night it was 'You can't criticise me. I'm Stuart Broad and I've been in the team for a long time.'"

Broad during the second Test between England and Pakistan at Headingley cricket ground.
Broad during the second Test between England and Pakistan at Headingley cricket ground.

Former Yorkshire and England batsman Vaughan, who played the last of his 82 Tests a decade ago, warned the hosts they had much work still to do if they were to avoid a third straight series loss after defeats in Australia and New Zealand.

"They haven't won this Test match yet," said Vaughan, 43.

"The comments last night were geared as though they had won the game.

"He (Broad) is a senior member of the team, and I don't think it was the right time to plan that attack," insisted Vaughan, England's captain when Broad made his Test debut away to Sri Lanka in 2007.

Broad phoned Vaughan to talk about his former skipper's remarks following England's loss at Lord's - their sixth defeat in eight Test matches.

"A private conversation is a private conversation, and it will remain between myself and Stuart," Vaughan said.

"(But) I just look at performances - and over the last year.

"It has been very comfortable for a long period of time … if the criticism over the last few days has geed them up to go out there and prove us wrong, great," he added.

But as for the idea that Vaughan's remarks had spurred him on to success, Broad said Friday: "I don't think it stung me into action."



PETITION: Thousands sign to stop cashless welfare card

premium_icon PETITION: Thousands sign to stop cashless welfare card

Kathryn Wilkes has campaigned against the welfare card for years.

EXPOSED: Woman's cancer scam rocks community

premium_icon EXPOSED: Woman's cancer scam rocks community

Alana Porter faked a cancer diagnosis for three years