Money well spent? Weighing up the cost of cashless cards

GOING DOWN: Human Services Minister Alan Tudge said the system had been expensive to set up but ongoing costs would reduce as time went on.
GOING DOWN: Human Services Minister Alan Tudge said the system had been expensive to set up but ongoing costs would reduce as time went on. Contributed

In the third part of our cashless welfare card series, the NewsMail looks at the cost of rolling the scheme out in Bundaberg.

THE cost of the cashless card trial to the Federal Government was $18.9 million.

Indue, the private company that ran the trial, was paid at least $7.9m, while the government spent $2.6m on its own administrative costs and $2.6m on support services.

With 1850 participants, the final bill for each person came in at $10,000.

A Newstart recipient receives about $14,000 in benefits a year.

Under the cashless card, some welfare recipients have 80% of their benefits quarantined so it cannot be used to buy alcohol, gamble or withdraw cash.

SA Greens Upper House MP Tammy Franks said it was ludicrous to pay $10,000 per person to run the trial.

"Someone's making a profit here and it's certainly not those who most need it,” she said.

But the government said the cashless card roll-out would be different and would not necessarily be run by Indue.

All merchants would be automatically switched on to accept the card - except those who sell alcohol or gambling products.

Only mixed merchants (those selling alcohol or gambling with other products) would need to go through a process with the Department of Social Services, resulting in an agreement being that the merchant agrees not to sell banned products via cashless cards. There is no cost to merchants.

But Human Services Minister Alan Tudge said the system had been expensive to set up but ongoing costs were much smaller and would reduce as time went on.

Member for Bundaberg Leanne Donaldson said small business in Ceduna had been adversely affected by the cashless card.

Ceduna business owner Malcolm Spry told the Guardian he was out of pocket by $100,000 - but he provided goods to customers on credit and those people reneged on repaying him.

Mr Spry said that had not happened before the cashless card trial, and he said he believed it's because the government had taken away recipients' ability to manage their budgets.

Independent research of the trial sites largely ignored the economic impact of the cashless card.

However, it did find that 78% of participants in both trial sites, Ceduna and East Kimberley, had not changed where and how they shopped since the change.

Only 18% expressed concern about their ability to access allowable goods and services.

Some stakeholders in Ceduna reported issues with people having enough cash to buy from second-hand websites, sport club canteens and community event tickets.

In East Kimberley, it was reported the card did not always work.

The report also found people with cashless cards bought more fruit and vegetables than they did previously.

TOMORROW: Part 4 - Social impact

Topics:  alan tudge cashless card cashless welfare card ceduna east kimberley federal government

Easement unease made feuding neighbours displeased

The Larsons faced serious charges but a magistrate earlier heard their neighbour brandished a meat cleaver.

Feud over easement sparks Mothar Mountain mayhem

Bundy woman says dog who could be killed saved her life

Karina Weston.

Morning hearing will determine dog's fate

Nurse in $17K Centrelink fraud while earning $107K

GUILTY PLEAS: Nurse Suzanne Filmer, 54, outside court yesterday.

Five years later she's only repaid $321

Local Partners

Swapping the keyboard for a drip torch

AFTER a day at the NewsMail office it was time to hang up the reporter hat and pop on my firefighter helmet.

Working class? Man, Gympie's got the show for you

Jimmy Barnes

Aussie rock icons coming to Gympie for 150th celebrations.

Tables turn as rescue crew takes on gruelling mountain

EPIC CHALLENGE: Hundreds of runners will tackle the 4.2km run from the heart of Pomona to the top of Mt Cooroora and back on Sunday.

They are usually the people coming to the rescue of adventurers

Artists to hit the stage for Childers Festival

LIVE LINE-UP: Mzaza will hit the stage at the Childers Festival next weekend, along with many other cultural performers.

Array of cultural performances on show next weekend

Holy schnit: This steak's the size of a small child

It's not every day you get served a steak as big as a baby for lunch, unless you're eating at the Pinnacle Pub.

OJ loses cool as he begs to go free

Simpson was convicted in 2008 of enlisting some men he barely knew, including two who had guns, to retrieve from two sports collectables sellers some items that Simpson said were stolen from him a decade earlier.

Tension at the parole hearing didn't stop OJ going free

Lead singer of Linkin Park, Chester Bennington, dies age 41

Coroner spokesman Brian Elias says they are investigating Bennington's death as an apparent suicide but no additional details are available.

Chester Bennington's body was found in LA at 9am local time.

Tamara's bittersweet MasterChef exit (take two)

Mackay's Tamara Graffen has already gained valuable work experience since her elimination from MasterChef.

MACKAY cook's heartwarming send-off from finals week.

Bundy woman wins $20k New York acting school scholarship

Former Bundaberg High School student Alana Bellert made it to the semi-finals of the modelling competition of the World Championships of Performing Arts at Los Angeles and has won a scholarship to a prestigious New York acting school.

'It's the Olympics for acting, dancing, modelling and singing'

Why Sleeping Duck turned down a $500,000 offer on Shark Tank

Sleeping Duck founders Selvam Sinnappan, left, and Winston Wijeyeratne.Source:Supplied

Melbourne university mates turn down hug Shark Tank ffer

Alex beach or bluff at your front door

ALEX LIVING: 9/252 Alexandra Pde, Alexandra Headland.

Beachfront unit among the picks of this week's auction line-up

Open for inspection homes 20 - 26 July

Check out this weekend's homes open for inspection.

Sunshine Coast shopping centre on the market

Coles-anchored centre in high-growth area listed for sale

Island resort living from just $250 a week

Couran Cove on Stradbroke Island is undergoing a makeover. Photo: Steve Holland

Resort offering permanent rentals at almost half normal rental price