Dying baby blackmailer’s ‘cruelty’ lashed by judge

A judge has ripped into the "extraordinary cruelty" of a woman who blackmailed the Melbourne parents of a dying baby girl.

Siti Kamal saw an opportunity in distraught dad Jay Windross' social media plea for the return of his wife Deanne's phone, filled with pictures of their terminally ill 11-month-old, Amiyah.

As the baby drew her last breaths in April last year, Kamal sent Mr Windross more than 90 messages demanding $1000 in return for the phone.

Despite never having the device, the 24-year-old threatened to sell it or delete the pictures of Amiyah.

Kamal exchanged nearly 160 messages with Mr Windross in 24 hours, including after Amiyah's death from an undiagnosed neurological condition.

County Court of Victoria Judge Elizabeth Gaynor berated Kamal for her "extraordinary cruelty" in the face of "indescribable anguish".

 

Siti Nurhidayah Kamal who attempted to swindle grieving parents out of $1,000 just days before their baby daughter died. Photos: Facebook
Siti Nurhidayah Kamal who attempted to swindle grieving parents out of $1,000 just days before their baby daughter died. Photos: Facebook

 

"You've got a couple spending their last days with their dying child," the judge told Kamal during a plea hearing on Monday.

"In a situation of almost indescribable anguish ... I can hardly think of a worse case (of blackmail).

"The extraordinary cruelty that this involved is a concern."

Kamal, aged 24 at the time, has pleaded guilty to blackmail and spent nearly 10 months in pre-sentence detention.

Court documents reveal Mr Windross pleading via WhatsApp for Kamal to return the phone, lost at Chadstone Shopping Centre on April 20.

The Samsung S8 had hundreds of photos of Amiyah on it and was not backed up. It's still missing.

After Amiyah died early on April 24, Mr Windross pleaded with Kamal not to delete the pictures.

 

Jay and Dee Windross, who lost their phone and were then blackmailed by Siti Kamal, who demanded money for the return of the phone, which containing photos of the Windross' now-deceased daughter. Picture: Andrew Henshaw
Jay and Dee Windross, who lost their phone and were then blackmailed by Siti Kamal, who demanded money for the return of the phone, which containing photos of the Windross' now-deceased daughter. Picture: Andrew Henshaw

 

"Please don't erase anything. Our baby passed away in our arms early this morning," he said.

"You have our memories of her. Please let us have some rest and then we will organise something. I promise."

It came after Kamal told told him: "please transfer me money I will return u (sic) the phone, or maybe I just sell it".

"You may help me today, god may help you," she also said.

Her barrister Rahmin De Kretser acknowledged Kamal would be handed a jail sentence but asked that be time she had already spent in custody.

"I accept that this is a morally indefensible crime," Mr De Kretser said. He asked Judge Gaynor to take into account Kamal's age, lack of criminal history, early guilty plea and problems with impulsivity.

 

Siti Nurhidayah Kamal (left), who attempted to swindle grieving parents out of $1000 as their baby daughter died. Photo: Facebook
Siti Nurhidayah Kamal (left), who attempted to swindle grieving parents out of $1000 as their baby daughter died. Photo: Facebook

 

She does not have a diagnosable disability or personality condition and the judge indicated she was preparing to hand down a longer jail sentence. "The only conclusion the court is left with is this was a deliberate, albeit impulsive, decision to act in an extraordinarily cruel way," Judge Gaynor said. "These victims were chosen because of their vulnerability.

"To see an opportunity in the suffering of others is extraordinarily concerning."

Kamal will be sentenced on March 10 and is likely to be deported to Malaysia after her release from jail.



As election nears, a wish list for road fixes is revealed

Premium Content As election nears, a wish list for road fixes is revealed

Bundy region roads named in list of trouble spots

Fears endangered fish are landing on dinner plates

Premium Content Fears endangered fish are landing on dinner plates

Endangered species being fished around the world, study says

The truth about working from home in Queensland

Premium Content The truth about working from home in Queensland

Queenslanders want mix of working from home and office