A MasterChef favourite went home on Sunday night. Picture: Channel 10
A MasterChef favourite went home on Sunday night. Picture: Channel 10

‘Confusing’ fish dish sends favourite home

Tracy Collins has said goodbye to the MasterChef: All Stars kitchen after her kingfish dish failed to impress the judges, with guest judge Josh Niland of Sydney's Saint Peter even calling it "an 11 out of 10 overcooked".

In a double-barrelled elimination challenge, the contestants were asked to identify several different types of fish - with some contestants floundering, and others snapping up a spot in the safe group.

RELATED: MasterChef viewers divided over Laura's 'smug' move

RELATED: How panic buyers impacted MasterChef's noodle challenge

For Laura, Emelia, Tracy, Reece and Khanh, their hopes of coasting through the first round to watch from the gantry were dashed, after they failed to correctly identify the fish they selected when it came to their turn.

Contestants were asked to identify the array of fish on display. Picture: Channel 10.
Contestants were asked to identify the array of fish on display. Picture: Channel 10.

In round two, the five chefs were tasked with cooking a cut of kingfish for Australia's own king of fish, Josh Niland.

While Laura's crispy-skinned dish was a winner, and Khan's broth "perfection", Emelia, Reece and Tracy failed to impress.

But Reece's slightly overcooked fish, and Emelia's salty sauce were safe against Tracy's plate of food - which left the judges vastly uninspired.

Mel’s face when she bit in to the overcooked fish said it all. Picture: Channel 10.
Mel’s face when she bit in to the overcooked fish said it all. Picture: Channel 10.

Grasping at straws - Andy complimented the corn, and Jock the seasoning, but judge Josh Niland seemed almost offended by the effort.

"Undeniably, overwhelmingly overcooked," a disappointed Mel commented.

"I think the best way to describe this dish is it was a confused cook. It did not come together cohesively," she added, with Jock chiming in: "That piece of fish was so overcooked it could pat its own back."

Tracy Collins was eliminated from MasterChef on Sunday night. Picture: Channel 10.
Tracy Collins was eliminated from MasterChef on Sunday night. Picture: Channel 10.

Breaking the news to a devastated Tracy, Jock said the dish wasn't appealing to look at, and the sauce didn't save it from the "fatty" taste of the fish.

Tracy appeared in six of MasterChef in 2014, and went on to open Harvest Kitchen in South Australia's Barossa Valley.

"I feel like I've learnt a lot as a person. I've really enjoyed meeting you all and the experiences we've had here. It's been truly unique and I'll honestly treasure it," she said through tears as she said her goodbyes.

MasterChef: All Stars continues Monday night from 7.30 on Channel 10.

Originally published as 'Confusing' fish dish sends favourite home



NO GO: Council puts brakes on plans for proposed servo

Premium Content NO GO: Council puts brakes on plans for proposed servo

During the BRC ordinary meeting Cr Dempsey said there had been extensive...

55 CHARGES: Man stole $8000 bike, credit cards in crime spree

Premium Content 55 CHARGES: Man stole $8000 bike, credit cards in crime...

MAGISTRATE: “You say you were hanging around with a bad crowd at the time, but...

Hard work pays off for go-getter with tourism partnership

Premium Content Hard work pays off for go-getter with tourism partnership

A young entrepreneur has been recognised for her creative talent, transforming her...