Business

Subsidies? At least be consistent

Allan Johnson
Allan Johnson Janie Kayes

A FEW weeks ago, I heard the government has decided local production of Holden cars is so important that we can afford to subsidise the operation for the next decade.

The amount of the subsidy is somewhere north of $200 million, and what do we get for our money?

We get continued employment for a number of South Australian workers, and of course protection for Australian manufacturing capabilities.

Of course, other car manufacturers enjoy the same privileges, so I was interested to read that South Australia's Centre for Economic Studies has suggested that the handouts are bad public policy.

But in case you are thinking I have an axe to grind with car manufacturers, let's move on to sports people. Once again, the government spends a considerable amount of our tax dollars supporting the development and promotion of our athletes, with a view to hearing our national song at international sporting events. Is this a good use of our money?

No doubt you can think of other areas where government subsidies are necessary to maintain the activity, and whether or not that is an appropriate use of taxpayer funds is always a matter for debate.

The same applies to rental property investors. Here we have a situation where many rental property owners rely on the support of taxpayer funds through tax advantages from negative gearing. These tax benefits are factored into the decisions that the investors make in assessing the risk of the investment. What do we (as the taxpaying public) get for this level of government subsidy?

The obvious answer is a large number of accommodation units for Australians who, for various reasons, do not own their own homes. The alternative is for the government to provide the housing (and I would suggest that the government would be a very bad landlord!). It is doubtful whether the government would be able to provide the same volume of housing by diverting the current subsidy to the acquisition of rental properties.

Unfortunately, whenever the subject of tax or economic reform is mentioned, negative gearing is almost inevitably cast as a blight on society. The social benefits of providing housing are quite clear, and the right of all property investors to engage in this legitimate business activity cannot be denied.

Any business owner is able to deduct all legal expenses incurred in earning income, so I always struggle to understand why the rules should be different if you are running a business of renting a property.

By all means, if we need to change the rules, the rules should change for everyone - not just a particular class of investment. Subsidising manufacturing jobs or athletic prowess should also be on the agenda. What do you think?

Topics:  car industry economy manufacturing protectionism subsidies



How to survive a bushfire in your car

IT SOUNDS like a nightmare, but it can happen.

Eight reasons to join the RFS

SPREAD across 93% of Queensland, the Rural Fire Service has about 36,000 volunteers. And you could be one of them.

What if my insurer gives me grief?

CLAIMING your insurance cover after a natural disaster can go one of two ways. It can be a breeze, or like pulling teeth.

Residents fed up with 'third world' communications

POOR RECEPTION: Residents have been frustrated by a lack of phone and internet services.

Gin Gin and Horse Camp residents fed up with lack of communications

Bundy mill busts 10-year record

SUGAR SUGAR: Things are looking sweet for growers in the region.

Increasing cane land part of the bigger plan

Police put youth on their side

Bundaberg Police Station in Bourbong Street.
Photo: Mike Knott / NewsMail

Big issues discussed

Local Partners

Rob's off to start a fresh new chapter

AFTER more than three decades delivering fruit and vegies to loyal customers across Bundaberg, Robert Ward is packing up his ute and retiring.


What's on: Saturday, December 3

Not sure what to do today? We've got you covered

Head to the sugar museum for a sweet taste of history

Cutting the ribbon to officially open the revamped Sugar Museum at Fairymead House is Mayor Jack Dempsey and Fairymead House Team Leader Hayley Vale.

Learn about the industry that made Bundy what it is

List of gigs happening around Bundy

KEY NOTE: Country singer Alex Peden. Photo: Scottie Simmonds / NewsMail

There's a live show for everyone

MOVIE REVIEW: Moana is an original adventure in paradise

The character Maui (Dwayne Johnson) in a scene from the movie Moana.

One Boxing Day animated film has a heart as big as the Pacific Ocean

MOVIE REVIEW: Singing the praises of a joyous animated film

The character Buster Moon in a scene from the movie Sing.

Animated film Sing hits all the right notes for family entertainment

Bundy singer working to make a brighter Christmas

Bundaberg musician Matthew Barker.

It's not 12 days of Christmas, but Seven Days of Umoja

Rogue One keeps Star Wars excitement alive

Felicity Jones in a scene from the movie Rogue One: A Star Wars Story.

GEORGE Lucas spin-off to hold fans over until Episode VIII.

MOVIE REVIEW: Bad Santa 2

Billy Bob Thornton and Brett Kelly in a scene from Bad Santa 2.

NAUGHTY Santa sequel falls flat.

Coldplay bathes Brisbane fans in sea of colour

Chris Martin, lead singer of British rock band Coldplay, performs at Suncorp Stadium in Brisbane. Coldplay are in Australia for a five-show tour. (AAP Image/Dan Peled)

Frontman Chris Martin drapes himself in Australian flag

Council opens up on 'secret' private development companies

Ipswich City Council Administration Building, South Street, Ipswich. Photo: Claudia Baxter / The Queensland Times

New website launched by Ipswich City Council

INSIDE STORY: The highlights of your $150 million CBD

GRAND PLAN: The highlights of the Ipswich CBD redevelopment and where they will be located.

Work on city heart's radical transformation to begin next year

VOTE IN OUR POLL: Sand mine opponents face serious dilemma

Public meeting for the proposed sand mine at Maroochydore last week.

Coast MP calls on Minister to stop KRA proposal with stroke of a pen

Developer's grand new multi-million dollar estate

NEW ESTATE: This is the only plan revealed by the property developer's new Billabongs Estate in Agnes Water.

DEVELOPER given the go ahead for a massive estate with 149 homes.

Couple's desperate $550K price drop to sell Gladstone home

Brian Headley and Kirstene Staib are selling their Kin Kora mansion for $750,000.

TELL tale sign of Gladstone's property market.

Ready to SELL your property?

Post Your Ad Here!